Magnetic Levitation Train in Nuremberg: Feasibility and Challenges Remain Unresolved
The prospect of a magnetic levitation (maglev) train in Nuremberg remains shrouded in uncertainty. Despite an announcement in autumn 2024, a feasibility study is yet to materialize. At the behest of the Nuremberg SPD parliamentary group, the city has now elaborated on the technical feasibility of the solution proposed by Minister-President Markus Söder (CSU).
The city’s assessment concludes that a maglev train is indeed technically feasible. However, its utility is deemed inferior to that of a tram. A shift from tram to maglev would result in an estimated 1,100 fewer passengers using the planned route per day compared to a continuous tram service. This would represent roughly a third of the projected daily passenger volume.
In terms of costs, both options are said to be comparable. However, the maglev is projected to be more cost-effective in operation due to its low wear and tear and greater potential for automation.
The pivotal question of financing remains unanswered. According to the city, this is primarily due to the uncertainty surrounding the eligibility of maglev projects for funding and, if so, the extent of such support. Key legal issues also remain unresolved at present.
The planned maglev route would run between the university, exhibition center, and hospital, following the same alignment as an already planned tram extension. Söder first announced the project in December 2023 during his inaugural policy statement following the state election. The Free State of Bavaria covered 90% of the €60,000 feasibility study costs.
Ongoing Concerns and Questions
Despite the progress in evaluating the technical feasibility of a maglev train, several key concerns and questions remain unresolved:
-
Funding: The absence of a concrete funding plan casts doubt on the project’s viability. The city emphasizes the need for clarity on potential financial support from the federal government or other sources.
-
Legal Framework: The legal framework for maglev trains in Germany is still in its infancy. Crucial issues, such as safety regulations, operating licenses, and liability, must be addressed before a maglev system can be implemented.
-
Passenger Acceptance: While the feasibility study indicates that a maglev could technically operate, it remains uncertain whether it would gain widespread acceptance among passengers. Concerns about cost, convenience, and potential noise pollution must be addressed.
-
Environmental Impact: The environmental impact of a maglev system needs to be thoroughly assessed. The construction and operation of the elevated track, as well as the potential for electromagnetic interference, must be carefully evaluated.
Next Steps
The next steps in the Maglev Nuremberg project are unclear. The completion of the feasibility study and a comprehensive funding plan are crucial for moving forward with the project. Additionally, the legal framework must be clarified, and public consultation is essential to address concerns and ensure broad support for the project.
Conclusion
The feasibility of a maglev train in Nuremberg remains an open question. While the technical assessment provides a promising foundation, significant challenges, including funding, legal issues, and passenger acceptance, must be addressed before the project can become a reality. As the city and state authorities continue to explore the Maglev Nuremberg project, a comprehensive and transparent approach is essential to build public trust and ensure the project’s long-term success.
