WWE Backlash Predictions: Will Nostalgia Prevail or Will New Stars Shine?

The dust has settled from WrestleMania 41, but the WWE Universe is already gearing up for Backlash, emanating from St. Louis. While it’s tempting to assume a post-WrestleMania lull, with champions holding firm, Backlash has a history of surprises. The card, though not boasting a lineup of all-time greats, presents compelling narratives and potential for impactful moments. Can hometown hero Randy Orton pull off an upset against John Cena in what’s billed as their final encounter? Will Lyra Valkyria continue her reign as Women’s Intercontinental Champion against the formidable Becky Lynch? And can Pat McAfee, making his return to the ring, withstand the brutal onslaught of Gunther? Let’s delve into the predictions from wrestling experts.

Gunther vs. Pat McAfee

All signs point to a dominant victory for Gunther. Jordan Mendoza emphasizes that McAfee’s skill level doesn’t compare, suggesting a crushing defeat that could lead to McAfee taking time off to recover. Richard Morin echoes this sentiment, arguing that Gunther needs to regain momentum after his World Heavyweight Championship loss at WrestleMania. A decisive win over McAfee would be a step in that direction. James H. Williams agrees, seeing McAfee’s participation as a way to attract viewers but not as a serious threat to Gunther. The consensus is clear: Gunther will inflict a punishing defeat on McAfee, re-establishing his dominance and potentially sidelining the charismatic commentator.

Prediction: Gunther

Lyra Valkyria (c) vs. Becky Lynch for the Women’s Intercontinental Championship

The dynamic between Valkyria and Lynch is captivating, with Lynch’s recent turn adding fuel to the fire. Jordan Mendoza highlights Valkyria’s improved substance as champion but notes that putting the title on Lynch would elevate its prestige. Mendoza predicts Bayley’s interference will allow Valkyria to retain. Richard Morin foresees similar interference from Bayley, who was previously attacked by Lynch. This could lead to a triple-threat match for the title in the future. James H. Williams believes Valkyria will seek revenge against Lynch for their recent split. While acknowledging the potential benefits of Lynch holding the title, he sees Valkyria retaining for now.

Prediction: Lyra Valkyria

Dominik Mysterio (c) vs. Penta for the Intercontinental Championship

This rematch is expected to be filled with drama and potential interference from The Judgment Day. Jordan Mendoza anticipates Mysterio retaining thanks to Judgment Day’s presence, with Finn Balor potentially snapping and attacking Mysterio afterward. Richard Morin notes that Mysterio and Penta recently faced off on Raw, with Mysterio winning due to Judgment Day’s help. He anticipates El Grande Americano appearing and attacking Penta, setting up a legitimate feud and progressing the Judgment Day storyline. James H. Williams emphasizes the strong reaction Dominik Mysterio received at WrestleMania, suggesting that he won’t be losing the title anytime soon, given Judgment Day’s support. Finn Balor’s role remains a wildcard.

Prediction: Dominik Mysterio

Jacob Fatu (c) vs. LA Knight vs. Drew McIntyre vs. Damian Priest for the United States Championship

This multi-person match promises high stakes and potential for chaos. Jordan Mendoza believes that Fatu’s momentum is too strong to be stopped. Richard Morin sees the inclusion of McIntyre and Priest as a way to legitimize Fatu, who defeated Knight for the title at WrestleMania 41. The potential for Solo Sikoa to turn on Fatu, or vice versa, adds another layer of intrigue. James H. Williams sees this match as a potential show-stealer. While acknowledging that anything can happen in a match where the champion doesn’t have to be pinned to lose the title, he predicts Fatu will overcome his opponents’ brawling style to retain.

Prediction: Jacob Fatu

John Cena (c) vs. Randy Orton

The nostalgia factor surrounding this match is undeniable. Jordan Mendoza anticipates a highly charged atmosphere and callbacks to their past encounters. While acknowledging Orton’s hometown advantage, he predicts Cena will win through underhanded tactics, continuing his storyline of "ruining wrestling" in his final year. Richard Morin uses a Shakespearian allusion to set the stage. He questions if this will be their final clash and suggests the match could set up another encounter later in the year. He predicts Travis Scott will interfere, attacking Orton and sidelining him for a while, leading to a dramatic return later this year for Orton to get even. James H. Williams notes the restoration of the Cena-Orton rivalry, expecting plenty of interest in how it plays out. He predicts Cena will find a way to retain, possibly with interference from Travis Scott or The Rock.

Prediction: John Cena