American Senators React to the Historic Election of Pope Leo XIV

The election of Pope Leo XIV, the first American-born pontiff, has sent ripples of excitement and anticipation across the United States, particularly on Capitol Hill. Fox News spoke with several senators from both sides of the aisle, gathering their reactions to this unprecedented event in the history of the Catholic Church.

Senator John Hoeven (R-N.D.): "Unbelievable"

Senator John Hoeven of North Dakota expressed sheer astonishment at the news. "Unbelievable," he exclaimed. "If you told me ahead of time, I’d have said, ‘No way. Never happen.’ This is phenomenal." Hoeven admitted to previously believing that an American cardinal would never be chosen as pope, anticipating that the selection would likely fall to a European candidate. "I’ve been telling folks they’ll never pick an American cardinal to be the pope. And I thought, you know, maybe somewhere else, but probably back to Europe. So, this is so exciting. I can’t believe it."

Hoeven emphasized the positive impact this historic election would have on American Catholics. "American Catholics are just going to be thrilled," he stated. "I know they’re just thrilled."

Senator Mark Kelly (D-Ariz.): "Incredibly Excited"

Senator Mark Kelly of Arizona echoed the sentiment of excitement, stating, "As an American Catholic, I am incredibly excited." Kelly injected a touch of humor into his reaction, quipping that "as an Arizonan, this is probably the best pick the Cardinals have made since Larry Fitzgerald," referencing the successful wide receiver of the Arizona Cardinals football team.

Senator Tammy Duckworth (D-Ill.): Pride for Illinois

Senator Tammy Duckworth of Illinois expressed pride in the newly elected pope’s American roots. "We’re very proud in Illinois," she said, hinting at the hope that Pope Leo XIV would "bring some of his hometown to the Vatican with him."

Who is Pope Leo XIV?

The newly elected Pope Leo XIV was born Robert Francis Prevost in Chicago in 1955. He is a member of the Augustinians, a religious order within the Catholic Church. Prevost received his education at Villanova University, was ordained a priest in 1982, and was elevated to the position of cardinal by Pope Francis in 2023.

Senator Ed Markey (D-Mass.): A Call for Compassion and Social Justice

Senator Ed Markey of Massachusetts focused his comments on Pope Leo XIV’s potential to influence political discourse and advocate for social justice. Markey referenced a past post by Leo on X, before his election, in which he appeared to critique Vice President JD Vance’s justification for stricter immigration enforcement.

"Hopefully, the new pope can use his pastoral powers in order to help JD Vance and Donald Trump understand their responsibilities representing the most powerful and wealthiest nation in the world," Markey said. "To ensure that we also protect those who are the most vulnerable and most in need."

Markey expressed his belief that Pope Leo XIV "will continue the legacy of Pope Francis" and that "this new pope channels that history of the Catholic Church, standing up for those who are most in need against those who are most powerful."

Differing from His Predecessor: Tradition and Symbolism

Despite Senator Markey’s assertions that Pope Leo XIV will follow in the footsteps of Pope Francis, the new pontiff has already signaled a departure from his predecessor in certain ways. These differences are largely symbolic, yet carry significance for those attuned to Catholic tradition.

One notable difference is the choice of papal name. Francis chose his name to honor St. Francis of Assisi, known for his poverty and simplicity. Leo, on the other hand, is a more traditional papal name, historically associated with strong leadership and intellectual prowess.

Another visible distinction is Pope Leo XIV’s decision to wear the traditional red cape of the papacy, a garment that Pope Francis chose to forgo after his election in 2013. This return to traditional papal attire has been interpreted by some as a sign of a more conservative approach to the papacy.

Pope Leo XIV’s First Words: A Message of Peace and Dialogue

After emerging to address the crowd assembled in St. Peter’s Square on Thursday, Pope Leo XIV’s first words were "Peace be with you," delivered in Italian. He then shared a message emphasizing the importance of building bridges, fostering peace, and engaging in dialogue "without fear." This message suggests a focus on unity and understanding, aiming to bring people together despite their differences.

A New Chapter for the Catholic Church

The election of Pope Leo XIV marks a significant turning point for the Catholic Church. As the first American-born pope, he brings a unique perspective and background to the papacy. His leadership will be closely watched as he navigates the complex challenges facing the Church in the 21st century, from declining membership in some regions to navigating social and political divisions.

His initial actions and statements indicate a desire to balance tradition with the need to adapt to modern realities. Whether he will embrace the progressive agenda of Pope Francis or chart a more conservative course remains to be seen. Regardless of his specific policies, the election of Pope Leo XIV has undoubtedly injected a renewed sense of excitement and hope into the Catholic community, both in the United States and around the world. The coming years will reveal the full impact of his papacy on the Church and its role in global affairs.

The reactions from American senators, ranging from astonishment and excitement to cautious optimism and calls for social justice, reflect the diverse perspectives and expectations surrounding this historic moment. As Pope Leo XIV begins his pontificate, the world will be watching closely to see how he leads the Catholic Church into the future.