Six Months with the Google Pixel Watch 3 (45mm): A Comprehensive Review

Six months have passed since the Pixel Watch 3 graced the market, and after extensive daily usage, it’s time to reflect on its performance, features, and overall impact on the smartwatch landscape. This review focuses primarily on the 45mm variant, noting that the 41mm model offers a largely identical experience unless specified.

Since the initial Pixel Watch launch alongside the Pixel 7 series, the Wear OS ecosystem has seen some brands retreat, inadvertently reducing the number of Wear OS device manufacturers. While this trend may seem unfavorable, it has, in effect, helped to highlight the quality offerings of the remaining players. With fewer Fossil-branded devices to contend with, the Pixel Watch 3 has less competition while serving as a benchmark for the Wear OS platform. With two distinct sizes available, Google provides the perfect opportunity to showcase its vision for the "ideal" Android accessory.

Software and Features: A Steady Stream of Improvements

Google’s software update strategy is a defining characteristic of its Pixel devices, and the Pixel Watch 3 is no exception. While the watch hasn’t received a flood of major overhauls, consistent updates have added functionality and addressed key areas. The long-awaited regulatory approval for loss of pulse detection significantly enhances the watch’s safety features, alerting users to potentially severe medical events and highlighting Google’s focus on user well-being.

Beyond crucial safety features, smaller updates have enhanced daily usability. Individual contact tiles provide quick access to frequently contacted individuals, streamlining communication. The enhancements to Gmail for Wear OS, including emoji reactions, allow for more expressive and efficient email replies. Google Wallet’s expansion to include hotel keys, campus IDs, and corporate badges solidify the Pixel Watch 3 as a versatile tool for your daily life.

Looking ahead, the integration of Gemini with Wear OS represents a major development to watch for. Leaked code suggests a voice-first approach that could revolutionize how users interact with their smartwatches. Imagine summarizing lengthy texts, drafting sophisticated replies, or receiving nuanced answers to complex questions, all through voice commands. The potential for extensions to expand and broaden Gemini’s capabilities is an undeniably exciting prospect. The brief appearance of a "Find My Device" app for Wear OS in a dedicated ad also sparks hope for improved device tracking.

However, Google has transitioned from monthly to quarterly updates for the Pixel Watch 3. While this change initially raised concerns, it may prove beneficial in the long run. Monthly security patches are arguably less critical for a wearable device, and this shift could potentially lead to more substantial feature releases and an improved overall software experience over time.

Design and Build Quality: A Balancing Act

The Pixel Watch’s signature design has been praised for its minimalist aesthetic and comfortable fit. The review questions whether there’s a better way to improve the ruggedness of the watch given tough scenarios. The sleek, pebble-like design suits various outfits, but it may not be the most durable option for demanding environments. The 45mm size offers a comfortable fit without looking overly small on the wrist.

The lack of official watch strap adapters remains a point of frustration. The proprietary connector system limits users to Google’s premium-priced bands or less-reliable third-party options. While Google’s first-party bands offer excellent quality, their price point can be prohibitive. The Active Sport band is a must-have for fitness enthusiasts, and the fine woven band provides a stylish option for everyday wear. However, the performance loop band is comfortable, but arguably overpriced.

The Gorilla Glass 5 display has held up remarkably well over six months of daily use, with only a few minor scuffs. While some users may prefer a more robust design, the Pixel Watch 3’s display has proven relatively durable. While the crown is now more resistant to scratches, the Hazel frame is prone to mini abrasions and scuffs. Protective cases can mitigate this issue, but choosing the right case is crucial, as some models can exacerbate the problem.

Fitness Tracking: Decent, but Not Exceptional

The Pixel Watch 3 caters to a broad range of activities, but it doesn’t provide the most in-depth fitness tracking capabilities. The Fitbit app’s design and integration limit some features. However, certain features, such as the cardio load metric, are valuable for optimizing training intensity and providing insights into recovery and performance.

Body response notifications, designed to alert users to heightened stress levels, are a welcome addition. This feature, coupled with Fitbit Relax, offers a holistic approach to stress management and differentiates Google’s wearable from the more fitness-oriented Galaxy Watch lineup.

The Pixel Watch 3 design is better than the competition for sleep wear. Sleep tracking and readiness scores offer valuable insights into sleep quality, but the value of this data remains subjective. The improved battery life of the 45mm Pixel Watch ensures that it can be worn overnight without significantly depleting the battery.

While Fitbit Premium offers advanced features, the basic functionality is often sufficient. Competitors such as the Galaxy Watch and recent OnePlus Watch offer deeper analysis for free, making Fitbit Premium difficult to recommend beyond the initial trial period. Fitbit needs to expand its functionality, and the Pixel Watch needs to offer a broader array of tracking modes and analyses.

Fitness tracking is not a key selling point. The limitations are apparent in the gym, where individual muscle group workouts are still missing. If you prioritize advanced fitness tracking features, the Pixel Watch 3 may not be the best option.

Performance and Wear OS: A Seamless Experience

Since its launch, there hasn’t been a huge shift in the Pixel Watch 3’s functionality. However, Feature Drops have added some new features, and Wear OS feels clean and light. Wear OS works fine as a notification bridge and for specific media apps.

The morning briefing feature provides a concise and customizable overview of health metrics. The 45mm version’s larger display provides more real estate for displaying information. The performance is excellent, and everything reacts instantly, although the Play Store can sometimes be slow when updating apps. The seamless integration with Google services is a key strength.

Watch Unlock is a great function, but it isn’t locked to the new hardware. The improved screen real estate with the 45mm Pixel Watch 3 is more than enough to consider.

The absence of Gemini integration is confusing, especially given its ubiquity across other Google platforms. While Google Assistant is useful for hands-free tasks, the potential for Gemini to revolutionize the Wear OS experience is undeniable. Features like starting workouts without diving into the Fitbit app or sending messages and playing playlists using voice commands are needed.

Battery Life: A Notable Improvement

The battery life of the 45mm Pixel Watch 3 represents a significant improvement over its predecessors. 24 hours of wear is easily achievable, and light usage can extend battery life to 48+ hours. Disabling GPS-intensive tasks and avoiding gym usage can further extend the battery life. Even with the AOD active, the battery life is more than enough. Charging speeds are reasonable, with the 45mm variant reaching a full charge in approximately 70 minutes. The lack of wireless charging is a disappointing omission. It would be great to have the option to top up the watch using reverse wireless charging on Pixel phones.

Conclusion: A Solid Choice, but Competition Looms

The Pixel Watch 3 is the best first-party wearable to date. The 45mm version is a superb addition to the lineup, offering a clean, integrated experience that seamlessly extends the functionality of your Pixel phone.

The 41mm variant is more difficult to recommend unless you prefer smaller watches. The minor upgrades over the Pixel Watch 2 may not be enough to justify an upgrade, and the battery life is not as extensive.

While high-quality Android smartwatches are not as ubiquitous as smartphones, the Pixel Watch 3 is a solid choice if you have a Pixel phone. However, the recently released OnePlus Watch 3 may be a more complete wearable if you don’t prioritize the Pixel aesthetic and features like Watch Unlock. The heavily discounted Galaxy Watch 7 series also offer alternative options.