The Podcast Divide: How Echo Chambers and Influencers Shape American Truth in 2025

This story was originally published in The Highlight, Vox’s member-exclusive magazine. To get early access to member-exclusive stories every month, join the Vox Membership program today.

The podcast landscape has transformed into a powerful force, shaping how Americans consume information and form opinions. Gone are the days when traditional media held exclusive sway; now, a diverse ecosystem of independent podcasters and charismatic personalities wield significant influence, often fostering echo chambers and exacerbating societal divisions. This shift became strikingly apparent when Kylie Kelce, a former field hockey coach and wife of NFL star Jason Kelce, unexpectedly topped podcast charts, dethroning the reigning king, Joe Rogan.

Kelce’s rise to podcast prominence with "Not Gonna Lie With Kylie Kelce" was a surprise to many, particularly Rogan’s dedicated fanbase. Her podcast, marketed as a platform for her views on motherhood, sports, and occasional political commentary, disrupted the male-dominated podcasting world. While shows like Alex Cooper’s “Call Her Daddy” have carved out successful niches, men like Rogan, Theo Von, and Andrew Huberman have typically dominated the top spots.

The initial shock of Kelce’s debut in December, which briefly ousted "The Joe Rogan Experience" from Apple’s No. 1 position and held the top spot on Spotify for 10 days, was met with skepticism. Some Rogan fans accused Kelce of artificially inflating her numbers, dismissing her as a "nobody." However, the two shows would continue to trade places on Spotify, and "Not Gonna Lie" consistently remains in the top 10, despite its weekly release schedule.

The reasons for Kelce’s success are multifaceted, including her connections to the Kelce and Taylor Swift families, her relatable discussions about motherhood and femininity, and the show’s relatively short length compared to other podcasts. Yet, her unexpected ascent and the subsequent reactions highlight a more significant trend in entertainment and news consumption in 2025: the fragmentation of audiences and the rise of individualized "realities."

Podcasts have swiftly evolved into a primary source of information for Americans. While traditional news broadcasts still exist, the most popular podcasts are often helmed by charismatic and relatable creators who offer a blend of news, political analysis, cultural commentary, and pop culture. These hosts frequently promise to deliver unfiltered truth and engage in conversations deemed too taboo for mainstream media.

However, this shift has also led to increased ideological segregation. Americans are increasingly gravitating towards podcasts that align with their existing beliefs, creating echo chambers where dissenting voices are rarely heard. This fragmentation grants these shows and their hosts unprecedented reach and influence, once exclusively reserved for established media outlets.

The combination of ideological polarization and the power of podcast hosts has given rise to distinct "realms of truth." These realms are shaped both by the hosts’ opinions and the specific events they choose to highlight for their listeners. Consequently, news and information are filtered to different groups of consumers in radically different ways, a trend that shows no signs of abating.

The 2024 presidential campaign showcased the growing importance of podcasts. Donald Trump strategically engaged with popular male podcast hosts for informal conversations, while Kamala Harris attempted to catch up by appearing on smaller, more liberal-leaning shows.

Podcast listenership has exploded in the past decade. From just over 10 percent of Americans listening monthly, the number has quadrupled to nearly half of the population over the age of 12, according to Edison Research’s "Infinite Dial" media survey in 2024. Furthermore, the landscape has shifted from one dominated by public radio and establishment institutions to a vast ecosystem of independent podcasters. As of 2023, less than 20 percent of the top 451 most-listened-to shows are associated with traditional news organizations.

While men, millennials, and older Americans were initially the primary podcast consumers, Gen Zers and women are now driving audience growth. Weekly or even daily discussions that blend news, politics, pop culture, sports, self-help advice, and personal stories have become a primary way for nearly a third of Americans to stay informed. A 2023 Pew Research Center report found that about two-thirds of American podcast listeners hear news "discussed" on their shows, even if it’s not the main reason they tune in.

However, the information listeners receive can vary dramatically depending on the host and the target audience. Fact and opinion often intertwine in conversations that filter information, and listeners may not necessarily be better informed as a result. This new breed of podcast, which mixes sports, pop culture, history, or lifestyle trends with current events, fosters a unique sense of intimacy and trust. Because these shows aren’t overtly political, audiences tend to be fiercely loyal. Although they may feature politicians or remain apolitical, these shows frequently blur the lines between news, opinion, and analysis.

Podcast hosts possess significant power to influence their listeners’ habits and actions. This influence explains why the podcast circuit was a central component of Trump’s campaign strategy and why it will continue to be crucial for political endeavors in the coming years.

The 2023 Pew study revealed concrete examples of this influence. Over half of listeners said a podcast had inspired them to watch a movie or read a book, while roughly four in ten had tried a new workout or diet. A core group of loyal followers are even willing to spend money and time based on podcast recommendations. At least one in ten listeners had joined an online discussion group, donated to, volunteered for, or attended a political event or cause, and almost a third had bought something promoted on a podcast.

This level of influence also implies that listeners expect podcasters to be truthful. An astounding 87 percent believe that the information they hear on these shows is "mostly accurate." A third even trust this information more than what they receive from other sources.

This trust is remarkable, particularly when compared to trust in news from social media or mainstream media. However, these shows often lack the editorial oversight and infrastructure necessary to fact-check and verify claims, making them potential vectors for misinformation.

This is particularly concerning within specific ideological communities. Republicans, or those leaning toward the GOP, exhibit high levels of loyalty and trust in these shows. They report, at significantly higher rates than Democrats, that they trust podcast news more than other sources, believing that these shows provide exclusive insights.

The most ideological listeners often gravitate toward content that confirms their existing beliefs, reinforcing echo chambers. Conservative Republicans are twice as likely as moderate Republicans to listen to political opinions that mostly align with their own views, according to Pew’s 2023 survey. The same holds true for liberal Democrats compared to moderate Democrats.

This ideological sorting extends to the listenership of popular podcasts. An Edison Research survey found that 54 percent of Rogan’s listeners leaned toward Trump before the presidential election, while only a quarter leaned toward Harris. "Call Her Daddy’s" listenership exhibited the opposite trend. "Pod Save America," a popular left-leaning show, caters almost exclusively to Democrats.

This dynamic, where audiences are fiercely loyal to their chosen hosts and less exposed to diverse perspectives, creates echo chambers that filter information and political discourse. It also explains why people within these different ideological realms are often surprised when they encounter viewpoints from outside their bubble, as was the case with Rogan’s fans when Kelce achieved success.

These segregated podcast realities are likely to persist. Given Trump’s success in the last election, it seems probable that liberals will seek to replicate or mimic the right’s strategies.

This context makes Kelce’s success particularly interesting. In analyzing Harris’s loss, some Democrats argued that their party had neglected the new media environment, especially the influence of podcasts. They believed that Trump had recognized this early on, prompted by his son Barron and younger campaign aides.

The theory emerged that Democrats needed to create their own liberal version of Rogan, developing an extensive network of relatable and trustworthy podcasters and influencers. The underlying concern was that these increasingly popular podcasts could reach and influence a vast number of Americans, and liberals lacked a comparable presence.

While a left-leaning podcasting ecosystem exists, it is less expansive and connected than its right-wing counterpart. Figures like streamer Hasan Piker, the Chapo Trap House network, and the "Pod Save America" hosts command loyal followings, but their reach is more diffuse than that of the conservative "manosphere," which seemed better organized around political goals in 2024.

This suggests that there is potential for growth on the left. Podcasters are innovating to attract audiences, experimenting with livestreams, video content, and closer relationships with listeners. Young people, in particular, are eager for this type of content, especially on YouTube, now the leading podcast hosting service.

“We’ll see more movement there in terms of shows adding video components to podcasts, and that could be an area that explodes in the coming months, because [creators are seeing] … young people love to keep YouTube streams on in the background, or YouTube shows on in the background while [doing other things],” said Rachel Janfaza, a Gen Z political consultant.

Kelce’s position, along with other liberal and female hosts like Alex Cooper, is intriguing to watch. There are vast and growing audiences that these hosts could potentially capture, especially among young, female, and liberal listeners. Kelce has revealed that her politics "aggressively" lean left, and she has expressed interest in interviewing figures like Michelle Obama and Gov. Josh Shapiro, leading some to speculate whether she could be the "left’s Joe Rogan."

However, based on her initial episodes, Kelce isn’t aggressively pursuing this role. She’s not delving into analysis of the Biden presidency or Trump’s term. Instead, she’s speaking with guests about the realities of motherhood, the costs of childcare, the challenges of raising young boys, and the future of TikTok. Perhaps that is her strategy. By not explicitly focusing on divisive political issues she is cultivating a broad audience that will grow to trust her.