Cynthia Erivo: From "The Outsider" to "Poker Face" and Beyond
Cynthia Erivo is currently captivating audiences in the season two premiere of "Poker Face" on Peacock, delivering a "gangbusters" performance as multiple identical siblings entangled in a complex murder mystery alongside Natasha Lyonne’s Charlie Cale. While many now immediately recognize Erivo for her upcoming role as Elphaba in the highly anticipated "Wicked" film adaptation, it’s worth revisiting one of her earlier, impactful roles that showcased her undeniable talent: HBO’s "The Outsider."
Released in early 2020, coinciding with Erivo’s first Oscar nomination for her portrayal of Harriet Tubman in "Harriet," "The Outsider" served as a compelling introduction for many viewers to her acting prowess. The series, based on Stephen King’s 2018 novel of the same name, benefited from the author’s widespread appeal and featured a stellar cast, including Jason Bateman, Ben Mendelsohn, Paddy Considine, and Yul Vasquez. However, even among such accomplished actors, Erivo’s performance stood out, leaving a lasting impression on those who watched.
In "The Outsider," Erivo embodies Holly Gibney, a recurring character within Stephen King’s literary universe. Holly first appeared in King’s 2014 novel "Mr. Mercedes," where she was portrayed by Justine Lupe in the television adaptation. Her character continues to evolve and remains relevant, as she stars as the central figure in King’s latest novel, "Holly," released in September 2023.
Within the narrative of "The Outsider," Holly Gibney assumes the role of co-lead alongside Ben Mendelsohn’s Ralph Anderson, a seasoned Georgia detective grappling with personal struggles while investigating an inexplicable crime. The story begins with the gruesome murder of a young boy. The evidence unequivocally points to Terry Maitland (Bateman), a well-respected local baseball coach. Terry maintains his innocence, but circumstances appear overwhelmingly against him. Before his arraignment, Terry is killed. Ralph, a dedicated and experienced detective, is deeply troubled by the case. Despite the apparent evidence, he cannot shake the feeling that Terry was somehow telling the truth.
Recognizing the unusual nature of the crime, Ralph seeks the assistance of an unconventional investigator: Holly Gibney, played by Erivo. Holly possesses unique abilities that set her apart. She exhibits heightened perception, bordering on extrasensory perception, and displays peculiar knowledge, such as knowing the lyrics to songs she has never encountered before. These attributes make her an ideal foil for Ralph, a pragmatic and logical man who suddenly confronts the possibility of a supernatural explanation.
Erivo imbues Holly Gibney with a captivating blend of vulnerability, eccentricity, and unwavering determination. She fearlessly embraces Holly’s quirks and vulnerabilities, creating a character that is both relatable and enigmatic. Erivo’s portrayal captures Holly’s keen intellect and her empathetic nature. She delivers a performance that is both nuanced and powerful, solidifying her status as a rising star. Her portrayal also highlights the character’s struggle to reconcile her extraordinary abilities with the skepticism and disbelief she encounters from others.
"The Outsider" unfolds as a chilling and engrossing narrative. Over ten episodes, the series delves into a realm of suspense and darkness, creating a pervasive atmosphere of unease and dread. The series explores the themes of grief, guilt, and the struggle between good and evil, while prompting contemplation on the nature of belief. The ending, while providing a resolution, leaves viewers yearning for more, a testament to the show’s immersive storytelling.
Despite the lack of a second season for "The Outsider," Erivo has continued to shine in other projects. She has wowed audiences with her musical talents, delivered captivating performances in film and television, and now enthralls fans in "Poker Face." But her captivating turn as Holly Gibney in "The Outsider" remains a noteworthy moment in her career, demonstrating her ability to command the screen and leave a lasting impact.
"The Outsider" is currently available for streaming on Max. "Poker Face" is streaming on Peacock.
