Brooklyn Family Narrowly Escapes Falling Tree in Miraculous Incident
A Brooklyn family experienced a terrifying ordeal when a large tree unexpectedly toppled onto the sidewalk where they were walking, narrowly avoiding a potentially fatal accident. The incident, captured on surveillance footage, occurred on March 1st along 59th Street in the Bensonhurst neighborhood, according to details provided by Storyful. The footage, obtained by USA TODAY, offers a dramatic glimpse of the near-miss, underscoring the unpredictable nature of urban environments and the potential dangers lurking even in seemingly safe spaces.
Ben and Shelly Kerstein, two members of the family caught in the incident, recounted their experience to PIX 11, describing the event as nothing short of a miracle. They emphasized the sheer luck that allowed them to escape unharmed. "We ran and the whole thing splintered to pieces, and because it was so old, it splintered to dust," Shelly Kerstein explained, conveying the force of the impact and the deteriorated condition of the tree. She added that the video vividly captures their state of shock and disbelief after the close call, highlighting the psychological impact of such a traumatic event.
The surveillance footage likely shows the family walking along the sidewalk, perhaps engaged in conversation or simply enjoying a stroll, when the tree, seemingly without warning, begins to fall. The Kersteins’ reaction would likely be one of initial confusion, quickly turning to panic as they realize the imminent danger. Their instinctive reaction to flee, as Shelly described, was undoubtedly crucial in avoiding serious injury or even death. The subsequent splintering and disintegration of the tree upon impact would have added to the chaos and the sense of disbelief at what had just transpired.
While the Kersteins’ experience is certainly harrowing, it raises broader questions about the safety of urban trees and the measures in place to prevent such incidents. The condition of the tree, described as "old" and prone to splintering, suggests a potential lack of proper maintenance or assessment. Urban trees, while adding aesthetic value and providing environmental benefits, require regular inspection and care to ensure they do not pose a risk to public safety. Factors such as age, disease, structural defects, and weather conditions can all contribute to the likelihood of a tree falling.
Interestingly, statistical data suggests that the risk of being injured by falling trees is relatively low. Research findings published by the National Library of Medicine, based on a retrospective review of 13,844 trauma admissions related to accidental tree failures from January 2013 to June 2021, indicate that such incidents are rare. This data provides a broader context for understanding the Kersteins’ experience, highlighting that while the event was certainly frightening, it is statistically uncommon.
Similarly, Forest Research, a research organization providing services to the United Kingdom and international forestry interests, reports that only around six people per year are killed by falling trees or branches in the UK. Given the UK’s population of approximately 60 million, this translates to a one in 10 million chance of dying from a falling tree, or a one in 20 million chance of being killed by a tree in a public open space. These figures further emphasize the relatively low probability of fatal tree-related accidents.
However, these statistics should not diminish the significance of the Kersteins’ near-miss or the importance of proactive tree management. While the overall risk may be low, the potential consequences of a falling tree can be devastating. The Kersteins’ experience serves as a stark reminder of the need for vigilance and responsible tree care, particularly in densely populated urban areas where trees are in close proximity to people and property.
Following this incident, it is likely that the New York City Parks Department or other relevant authorities would investigate the condition of trees in the Bensonhurst neighborhood, particularly along 59th Street. This investigation would likely involve a thorough assessment of tree health, structural integrity, and potential hazards. Based on the findings, appropriate measures would be taken, such as pruning, bracing, or even removal of trees deemed to be at risk of falling.
The incident also underscores the importance of public awareness and education regarding tree safety. Residents should be encouraged to report any concerns about potentially hazardous trees to the relevant authorities. This could include trees that appear to be dead, diseased, or structurally unstable. By working together, residents and authorities can help to ensure the safety of urban environments and minimize the risk of tree-related accidents.
Ultimately, the Kersteins’ story is a testament to the power of chance and the fragility of life. While statistical data may provide a sense of reassurance, individual experiences like this serve as a potent reminder of the potential dangers that can arise from seemingly ordinary circumstances. The incident should prompt a renewed focus on tree safety and proactive measures to prevent future accidents, ensuring that urban environments remain safe and enjoyable for all. The family’s incredible escape, deemed a miracle by those involved, provides a sobering lesson and a call to action for responsible tree management and public awareness.
