Bengals’ Defensive Dilemma: Prioritizing Offense Over Defense?
The Cincinnati Bengals’ failure to reach the playoffs last season has been widely attributed to a struggling defense. Despite this glaring weakness, recent reports suggest the team’s front office isn’t prioritizing a defensive overhaul, raising questions about their strategic approach. The decision to potentially trade star defensive end Trey Hendrickson, who led the entire NFL in sacks last season, has ignited controversy and fueled speculation about the Bengals’ long-term plans.
Hendrickson’s possible departure comes at a critical juncture for the Bengals. The 30-year-old pass rusher recorded a career-best 17.5 sacks in the 2024 season, solidifying his position as the linchpin of the Bengals’ defense. Trading him would undoubtedly create a significant void in their defensive lineup and put immense pressure on other players to compensate for his absence.
The Bengals’ apparent indifference towards reinforcing their defense stems from their commitment to retaining their star offensive duo: wide receivers Ja’Marr Chase and Tee Higgins. Both receivers are poised to command hefty contracts, placing a considerable strain on the team’s salary cap.
Director of player personnel Duke Tobin openly acknowledged the financial implications during the NFL Scouting Combine, stating that Chase, who achieved a rare receiving triple crown last season, is expected to become the highest-paid non-quarterback in the league. This declaration underscores the Bengals’ unwavering belief in Chase’s value and their willingness to invest heavily in his long-term future.
Meanwhile, Higgins, who received the Bengals’ franchise tag, is also in negotiations for a long-term contract extension. Securing both Chase and Higgins will undoubtedly require a substantial financial commitment, potentially forcing the Bengals to make tough decisions in other areas, including the defense.
The Bengals’ offensive focus is understandable, considering the pivotal role quarterback Joe Burrow plays in their success. Burrow, who was firmly in the MVP conversation last season, showcased his exceptional talent by leading the NFL with 4,918 passing yards and 43 touchdowns. He finished fourth in the MVP voting, and his connection with Chase and Higgins was undeniable.
Chase and Higgins accounted for a staggering 2,619 of Burrow’s passing yards last season. Their ability to consistently make game-changing plays elevates the Bengals’ offense to an elite level, making them a formidable threat to any opponent. The Bengals’ decision to prioritize their offensive stars reflects their belief in Burrow’s potential to lead them to a Super Bowl victory.
However, neglecting the defense could prove to be a costly mistake. While a potent offense can certainly win games, a balanced team with a solid defense is often necessary for sustained success and championship contention. The Bengals’ defensive struggles last season exposed their vulnerability and ultimately contributed to their playoff absence.
Furthermore, the news of Hendrickson potentially being traded comes shortly after the retirement of veteran defensive end Sam Hubbard, who called it quits earlier this week at the age of 29. Hubbard’s departure further weakens the Bengals’ defensive line, adding to the concerns surrounding their defense.
Hendrickson, who will turn 31 this upcoming December, has been an exceptional asset to the Bengals since joining the team in 2021. Prior to his arrival in Cincinnati, Hendrickson spent his first four seasons with the New Orleans Saints. While he showed promise during his final season in New Orleans, recording a career-high 13.5 sacks, he truly blossomed after joining the Bengals.
Since becoming a Bengal, Hendrickson has consistently delivered outstanding performances, posting at least 14 sacks in three of his four seasons. His exceptional play has earned him Pro Bowl selections in each of his seasons in Cincinnati, solidifying his status as one of the league’s premier pass rushers.
Hendrickson’s current contract carries a cap hit of nearly $19 million, and the Bengals could save approximately $16 million by trading or releasing him. This financial flexibility could be used to fund the extensions for Chase and Higgins. Hendrickson is slated to become a free agent after the 2025 season, adding another layer of complexity to the situation.
The Bengals’ dilemma highlights the difficult choices teams face when managing the salary cap and building a competitive roster. While securing their offensive stars is undoubtedly a priority, neglecting the defense could ultimately hinder their chances of achieving their Super Bowl aspirations. It remains to be seen whether the Bengals’ bet on their offense will pay off, or if their defensive shortcomings will continue to plague them.
