The NFL’s Coaching Carousel: Winners and Losers of the 2023 Hiring and Firing Season
The NFL’s coaching carousel has come to a halt after a whirlwind of activity that spanned over four months. From the dismissal of Robert Saleh in October to the appointment of Kellen Moore in February, seven teams underwent leadership changes at the top. While this turnover is a recurring pattern in the league, this cycle has brought about several unexpected outcomes.
Winners
#1. Chicago Bears: Landing Ben Johnson as Head Coach
The Bears, starved for success over the past decade, have secured a highly sought-after head coaching candidate in Ben Johnson. Johnson’s reputation as an astute play-caller, honed during his tenure as the Detroit Lions’ offensive coordinator, has made him a coveted figure. His emphasis on player connection and understanding of the game bodes well for the Bears, who are desperate for a resurgence.
#2. New England Patriots: Acquiring Mike Vrabel as Head Coach
After a tumultuous season and public apologies from team owner Robert Kraft, the Patriots have landed a proven winner in Mike Vrabel. Vrabel’s experience as a linebacker for the Patriots and as head coach of the Tennessee Titans has instilled in him a no-nonsense approach. His commitment to surrounding his quarterback with capable personnel and fostering a competitive culture is expected to rejuvenate the Patriots’ fortunes.
#3. New York Jets: Stability under Aaron Glenn and Darren Mougey
Amidst dysfunction and rumors of internal conflicts, the Jets have discovered a glimmer of stability with their appointments of Aaron Glenn as head coach and Darren Mougey as general manager. Glenn’s reputation as a top defensive coordinator and Mougey’s experience in player personnel provide the Jets with the leadership they desperately need.
#4. Las Vegas Raiders: Bringing Back Jon Gruden as Head Coach
After a brief retirement, Jon Gruden has returned to the Raiders, becoming the oldest coach in NFL history. While his departure from the team in 2021 was acrimonious, Gruden’s success in his previous stint has generated optimism among fans and players alike.
#5. Houston Texans: Hiring Nick Caley as Offensive Coordinator
The Texans’ quarterback, Bryce Young, has faced significant setbacks due to protection problems and receiver injuries. The appointment of Nick Caley as offensive coordinator is expected to provide Young with the guidance and system he needs to thrive. Caley’s expertise in creating motion and empowering quarterbacks to make adjustments could be a game-changer for the Texans.
Losers
#1. Indianapolis Colts: Retaining Jeff Saturday as Head Coach
Despite a disappointing finish to the season, Jeff Saturday has been granted another chance as head coach of the Colts. While Saturday’s experience as a player is undeniable, his lack of coaching experience has raised concerns among fans and analysts. The Colts’ decision not to pursue more established candidates remains puzzling.
#2. Dallas Cowboys: Hiring Brian Schottenheimer as Offensive Coordinator
The Cowboys’ search for a new offensive coordinator has culminated in the appointment of Brian Schottenheimer, a polarizing figure in the league. Schottenheimer’s tenure as head coach of the New York Jets was lackluster, and his offensive schemes have been criticized for their predictability. The Cowboys’ decision to overlook more promising candidates has left fans disillusioned.
#3. Green Bay Packers: Uncertain Future for Aaron Rodgers
With the Jets ditching head coach Robert Saleh and hiring Aaron Glenn, the future of Aaron Rodgers in New York has become uncertain. Rodgers, reportedly eager to remain with the Jets, could explore other options, including the possibility of joining the Pittsburgh Steelers or taking a break from football.
#4. Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Losing Offensive Coordinator Liam Coen
The Buccaneers have lost their offensive coordinator, Liam Coen, who has returned to the Jacksonville Jaguars. Coen’s departure is a blow to the Buccaneers, who had witnessed their ground attack improve significantly under his leadership. Finding a suitable replacement who can maintain the team’s offensive success will be a challenge.
#5. Detroit Lions: Mass Exodus of Coaching Staff
The Lions have undergone a coaching exodus, losing not only Ben Johnson and Aaron Glenn but also six other assistants. The departure of key personnel, including passing game coordinator Tanner Engstrand and receivers coach Antwaan Randle El, has left the Lions with a void to fill. While the team has made some promising hires, the extent of the brain drain remains a concern.
Notable Trends
-
Lack of Minority Hires for Offensive Coordinator Positions: None of the 11 offensive coordinator hires were minority candidates, a trend that has raised questions about the league’s commitment to diversity.
-
Competition for Top Coaching Talent: Top candidates like Ben Johnson and Mike Vrabel were highly sought-after, highlighting the fierce competition among teams for the best available coaches.
-
Impact of College Salaries on NFL Hiring: Buckeyes offensive coordinator Chip Kelly left for the Raiders, lured by a significant salary increase. This trend suggests that the NFL will need to reassess its compensation structure to retain top talent from the collegiate ranks.
-
Uncertain Future for Jerod Mayo and Mike McCarthy: Former New England Patriots defensive coordinator Jerod Mayo remains without a coaching job, and Dallas Cowboys head coach Mike McCarthy is facing pressure after failing to reach the NFC Championship Game.
The NFL’s coaching carousel has spun rapidly, leaving behind a trail of winners and losers. As the teams prepare for the upcoming season, the success of these appointments will be closely scrutinized.
